'No hope' for rival bid for hotel
MARCH 27, 1999 -- WILLIAM E. Heinecke, CEO of Royal
Garden Resort group, yesterday poured cold water on Goldman Sachs and Bangkok Hotel
Holdings' Bt38-a-share counter-bid for Rajadamri Hotel Plc, saying that the rival tender
offer would not succeed since his group had a much better prospect of taking over the
operator of the five-star Regent Bangkok Hotel.
Heinecke said Royal Garden Resort will proceed with its tender offer for Rajadamri
Hotel at Bt27 a share now that it has reached an agreement with Mitsubishi Trust and
Banking Corporation to acquire a combined 32.3 per cent stake held in the Thai hotel firm
by Ransway Company Ltd and Rantack Company Ltd of Japan.
Mitsubishi Trust and Banking Corp is the financial adviser for the two firms, which are
holding the stakes in Rajadamri Hotel on behalf of EIE Insurance of Japan.
When combined -- the Japanese stake and its existing stake of 24.74 per cent, which it
bought from Tanayong Group last year at Bt25 a share -- Royal Garden Resort will emerge
with a total of 57.04 per cent in Rajadamri Hotel.
On March 8, 1999 Royal Garden Resort announced its tender offer for 10 per cent of
Rajadamri Hotel at Bt25 a share, with an anticipation that it would be able to secure the
32.3 per cent stake from Ransway Co and Rantack Co.
The stock price of Rajadamri Hotel jumped Bt7 yesterday to close at Bt30.50 on
anticipation of the Bt38-a-share counter-bid by Goldman Sachs and Bangkok Hotel Holdings.
However, most shareholders prefer to wait a little bit more for the development of the
takeover battle, as evidenced by the fact that only Bt790,000 in value changed hands
yesterday on the stock exchange.
Goldman Sachs and Bangkok Hotel Holdings, a joint venture between Charn Issara Group
and GS Emerging Market Real Estate Fund LP, sprang a surprise on Thursday when it
announced a counter-bid for Rajadamri Hotel for 100 per cent of its shares.
At the Bt38-a-share bid, Rajadamri Hotel is valued at Bt1.7 billion. However, the 100
per cent tender offer, which has already been filed with the Thai Securities and Exchange
Commission, is based on the condition that Goldman Sachs and Bangkok Hotel Holdings can
acquire a minimum 26 per cent in Rajadamri Hotel.
Korn Chatikavanij, managing director of JF Thanakom Ltd, the financial adviser of Royal
Garden Resort, warned against any market exuberance with the Goldman Sachs/Bangkok Hotel
Holdings' joint bid as only about 10 per cent of Rajadamri Hotel's stocks are freely
floated.
This puts Goldman Sachs and Bangkok Hotel Holdings' counter-bid at risk if it fails to
build up its stake in the hotel firm to 26 per cent -- a minimum level that must be
acquired otherwise the takeover can be scrapped.
''Investors must be wary about the small number of freely floated shares. If they jump
in to buy the stocks now with the hope of selling it off later at Bt38 a share, they might
be in for a disappointment. For the bid (from the rival party) will not proceed if it
fails to garner at least 26 per cent,'' Korn said.
Speaking from Hong Kong, Henry Cornell, the managing director of Goldman Sachs (Asia)
LLC, told The Nation that from his understanding, Royal Garden Resort has not reached any
agreement whatsoever with Ransway Co and Rantack Co to acquire their combined 32.3 per
cent stake in Rajadamri Hotel.
''The two Japanese firms or any shareholder in Rajadamri Hotel are free to sell their
shares,'' he said.
Over the past four weeks Ransway Co and Rantack Co have been holding a private auction
in Hong Kong to sell off their stakes in Rajadamri Hotel. The event, according to Cornell,
has attracted about a dozen of buyers, including Goldman Sachs/Bangkok Hotel Holdings and
Royal Garden Resort.
But since there is no clear outcome from the private auction, Goldman Sachs/Bangkok
Hotel Holdings has decided to launch its tender offer in the open market, putting its
tender price at 52 per cent higher than that of Royal Garden Resort.
''We want everyone to be happy. And in corporate democracy, everybody is free to sell
shares. It's up to the shareholders to decide who is offering the highest price,'' Cornell
said.
He added that his group believes in the long-term economic prospects of Thailand and
that the tourist industry will be a key positive factor in the development of the Thai
economy.
BY CHOOSAK JIRASAKUNTHAI and THANONG KHANTHONG
|