Prime Minister Chavalit Yongchaiyudh's U-turn on the oil tax and his lack of political
leverage to muster Cabinet approval for the financial reform package will not only cost
Thanong Bidaya his finance job but also push Thailand closer to bankruptcy.
After yesterday's meeting with Gen Prayudh Jarumanee, a military strongman and former
chairman of the Thai Military Bank, Thanong said he would re-examine his role in the
administration and announce his final decision before 6 pm today, one hour before the
prime minister is scheduled to negotiate the impending Cabinet reshuffle with Lt Gen
Chatichai Choonhavan, leader of the Chat Pattana Party.
Chatichai has made it clear that he would like to see sweeping changes in the Cabinet,
with his party assuming control of the key economic portfolios. Chat Pattana has been
fiercely criticised for hijacking the financial reform package, which was supposed to have
been approved by the Cabinet on Friday along with five Royal decrees and an amendment to
the Revenue Code.
Politically speaking, it is impossible for Thanong, a former banker, to continue his
job as finance minister when his fiscal consolidation package and financial reform package
have been gunned down by the coalition members of the Chavalit administration. Both
packages are crucial for winning the renewed confidence of the international community in
Thailand's macro-economic management, at a time that the private sector is seeking to roll
over its short-term external debts of US$30 billion.
They are also part of policy conditionalities agreed upon between the Royal Thai
Government and International Monetary Fund in return for support of a stand-by credit
worth $17.2 billion. Failure to implement the radical fiscal consolidation policy and
reform the financial sector will threaten the prospect of the Thai government receiving
the next payment in stand-by credit from the IMF.
Jaroong Nookwun, deputy governor of the Bank of Thailand, yesterday warned that a
change in the Finance portfolio will be sensitive at this time of economic difficulties,
particularly when it involves efforts to win back the confidence of international
investors. He added that Thanong played a very high profile role in negotiating a rollover
of Thailand's debts with the creditors in Japan and more recently in Hong Kong at the
annual World Bank/IMF meeting.
Dr Virabongsa Ramangkura, the deputy prime minister responsible for the IMF programme,
has expressed reservations over any hasty departure from this administration at a time
that his assignment remains unfinished. When Virabongsa first took over the deputy
premiership in August, he said his single aim was to help the country escape the economic
catastrophe. ''If I could push the country back one step from the edge of the cliff, then
I would consider that I was doing the job," he said then.
Yesterday Virabongsa, the conservative economist with strong backing from the military,
showed his determination to keep on fighting in the face of the government's backtrack on
the oil tax, which has greatly damaged the country's credibility in international eyes.
''My aim is to help tackle the economic problems. Insofar as there is still room for me to
do it, I will continue to do it," he emphasised.
Chavalit was forced to back-pedal on the Cabinet's decision to raise the oil tax by Bt1
per litre, designed to garner about Bt24 billion in tax revenue to keep the fiscal 1998
budget at a surplus of one per cent of the gross domestic product. The oil tax increase
along with a host of other luxury taxes and import duty hikes, which would have fetched a
total of Bt40 billion in fresh revenue has proved costly politically, with threats of
social and political unrest.
Korn Dabaransi, deputy prime minister and industry minister, quickly distanced his
party from the oil-tax hike, fearing political repercussions, although he was consulted
before Chavalit tried to ram the tax hike package through the Cabinet on Tuesday. On
Friday Chavalit bowed to political pressure by announcing that the oil tax increase would
be reversed to its original rate.
''Although the government has reversed its position on the oil tax to avoid domestic
backlash, it has lost the credibility and confidence of the international community and
international institutions," said Dr Nibhon Puapongkorn, vice president of the
Thailand Development Research Institute.
Without additional revenue from the oil tax, the government will be dipping into the
energy conservation fund now worth about Bt14 billion. This amount won't be enough to meet
the stringent fiscal consolidation requirements, and besides it will be depleted in six
months. The government has no immediate plan in hand to achieve the budget surplus.
''The reverse of the oil-tax increase shows that the government is not careful enough
in tackling economic problems and in its management of the tax revenue," charged
Tarrin Nimmanahaeminda, a former finance minister and now a Democrat.
With the fiscal 1998 budget hanging from a worn-out string and the financial reform
package subject to being watered down by politicians, attempts to put the Thai economy
back on track have now lost momentum although the Chavalit government appeared to make a
good start on Tuesday when the fiscal tightening policy and the financial reform package
were announced.
The two packages were described by Dr Prasarn Trairatvorakul, the deputy
secretary-general of the Securities and Exchange Commission, as ''substantive", which
should be able to win back confidence once the investors fully digested details. ''The key
components in unwinding the complications in the financial sector are also logical,"
he added.
The political infighting for power on Friday has dealt a heavy blow to Thailand's
efforts to achieve economic and financial reform. A radical political change is necessary
if Thailand is to escape from economic catastrophe. At this point, hopes are getting
dimmer indeed.