AFTER tedious negotiations which lasted more than 30 years, Thailand finally signed on
Nov 26, 1966, a treaty with the United States to avoid double taxation, bringing the
number of countries maintaining such bilateral treaties to 33.
The signing ceremony, witnessed by US President Bill Clinton, took place at the Royal
Grand Palace, with the then Finance Minister Amnuay Viravan and US Ambassador William
Itoh. Dr Amnuay still displays a photograph of this historic event in his living room.
The treaty, making double taxation or the levying of tax on the same revenue by both
governments obsolete, was off to a rocky start. As Dr Suvarn Valaisathien, a tax expert,
notes in his book ''Thai-US Double Tax Treaty'', the US government had initiated the
treaty in 1965.
Sensing that it was losing the Vietnam War and would some day have to retreat
militarily from the region, the US government feared it would create a ''political
vacuum'' and open the door for the communists to expand, he says. The original spirit of
the treaty had been aimed at encouraging US investors to establish their businesses here
because they would be provided with a seven per cent investment tax credit, a privilege
the US government had never extended to any other country before.
However, the treaty would only become effective after the Senate's ratification. As it
turned out, several US senators did not agree with the treaty because they saw it as being
discriminatory because it provided investment tax credit to US investors only in Thailand.
After that false start, the vicissitudes of the treaty made it all the more difficult for
both countries to conclude it.
The Bank of Thailand governor MR Chatu Mongol Sonakul was involved in the negotiations
from the beginning when he was a junior Finance Ministry official. He would work on the
treaty again in his capacity as the permanent-secretary for finance.
Indeed, the Thai side was quite reluctant to conclude the treaty this time, because,
aside from the problem with maritime tax concessions, it would dampen the privileges
provided by the Board of Investment.
The US also suspected the Thai side was not coming forth transparently by providing it
with the English version of any new laws or regulations which might have implications for
the treaty. Chatu Mongol said the Thai laws and regulations had never been officially
translated.
However, the US did not press for the treaty in the early '90s because then bilateral
trade ties had been strained over the issue of intellectual property rights. Later there
was weightier ground to push for the treaty, at least on the US's part, because Clinton
was then visiting the region. He attended the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation conference
in Manila before he flew to Thailand, and signing the treaty would make his visit more
important.
Meantime, Congress had endorsed a new draft which excluded the tax sparing clause,
which meant that the US would not recognise BoI tax privileges or waivers granted to US
companies in Thailand.
Suvarn has indeed written a remarkable book on the Thai-US tax treaty. The book,
published by Thammaniti Co Ltd, is priced at Bt180. The Harvard and George Washington
University graduate allocated his scarce time to academic research despite his heavy
business schedule. He approached the treaty with his impeccable scholarly skills, seeking
to explain, in layman terms, how Thai and US firms or individuals can benefit from this
treaty.
In essence, the treaty provides an exemption from Thai corporate income tax if a US
person does not have a ''permanent establishment'' in the Kingdom and the US government is
authorised to tax its own resident. Should a US person have a permanent establishment in
Thailand which shows profits Thailand will impose a corporate income tax on this income
and the US will credit the Thai tax against the US tax.
The full text of the treaty in Thai and English has been appended to the book. After a
brief introduction, which covers the background on the treaty's formation, Suvarn moves on
to explain how individuals or corporations can benefit from this treaty through tax
exemption, tax reduction and tax credit.
It also tackles the scope of the treaty, going into the definitions and details which
cover personal scope, taxes covered, benefits, limitations on benefits, artists and
sportsmen, social security payments, government service, students and trainees, teachers,
termination, and so on.
The book is an excellent reference for both American and Thai investors along with
legal scholars. Despite some technical terms, it is a good read for the scholars of law or
others wishing to gain an insight into the Thai-US double tax treaty. Suvarn is not only
reputed as a strong legal counsellor, he is also a first rate writer, both in Thai and
English.
BY THANONG KHANTHONG